COMMENTS BY EMINENT PERSONALITIES

(ENGLISH TEXT/TEXTE ANGLAIS)


Please have patience while this page is loading; the content is worth the wait!


The following comments by various composers and music critics are listed in a press release produced by Mme. Haïk-Vantoura and reproduced in her melody-only score, LES 150 PSAUMES. This is the English text of the comments. (Other comments are added in the French and English editions of her book.)

It is with greatest interest that I listened to the recording of the magnificent music you reconstituted for the Psalms of the Bible. I admired the intimate harmony that exists between words and music, expressing in turn ardent faith and hope, with moving accents that touch the heart. It heralds plainsong…

Marcel DUPRE
Member of the Institute of France, Former Director at the Conservatoire National Supérieur de Musique de Paris

Admirable are the patience and faith with which this outstanding musician has managed to accomplish so ambitious a task. Instinct and reason, wisdom, sensitivity and intelligence also served her in her pursuit (…) How can one not be impressed by the alluring poetry which pervades the musical texts, drawing them so harmoniously closer to the literary texts, and bestowing upon them such an accent of authenticity?

Henri DUTILLEUX
Composer, Professor of Composition at the Conservatoire National Superieur de Musique de Paris

…Like Champollion facing hieroglyphics you have sought the key to the enigma. By repeated experimentation, comparison and hypotheses verified one by one, you have established the musical meaning of these enigmatic signs (…) Humble and haunting is the way this music appears to us, unearthed from ages and thousands of years old (…) A fundamental discovery -- perhaps one of the most significant of this half century. Could world music have a single source?

Bernard GAVOTY
Music critic / Member of the Institute of France

…I read your book with very great interest during a holiday in Jerusalem and want to express to you all my admiration for your fine and very thorough work that is so convincing. I wish you all the success it amply deserves.

Ernest GUGENHEIM
Chief Rabbi, Former Director of the Ecole Rabbinique de France

…The melodies you have recorded are moving to hear in their restitution of our ancient airs. As for your book: THE MUSIC OF THE BIBLE REVEALED, this work will bear authority. I heartily congratulate you on it.

Jacob KAPLAN
Chief Rabbi of France

…It took a valiant musician to delve into the enigma with passion, patience and thoroughness and little by little emerged the marvelous monodies buried under the dust of centuries. (…) Starting with precise points, obvious cadences, Madame HAÏK-VANTOURA managed to find the "Ariadne's thread" leading to the stupefying discovery of an entire art dating back to Antiquity. (…) This revelation takes on vital importance from both a musical and historical point of view.

Daniel LESUR
Honor. Inspector General of Music at the Ministry of Culture

I must tell you that I find this work completely remarkable and I emphasize the seriousness as well as the undeniable logic of your interpretation (…) I am happy that we in Israel had the opportunity to learn about this new decipherment which, I hope, will become dominant in the near future. In regards to this you may count on my help.

Ami MAAYANI
President of the League of Composers in Israel and Professor in the Department of Theory and Composition at the Rubin Academy of Music and Dance, Jerusalem

As a musician and deeply devout, I can only admire the beauty of the biblical musical texts reconstituted by Madame Suzanne HAÏK-VANTOURA. The biblical music offered to us here approaches the Gregorian cantilena and the semi-chromatic modes of India (in much simpler form in both cases). Since biblical music preceded these two great traditions, it is thrilling to be able to sing or hear sung the result of the immense work of Suzanne HAÏK-VANTOURA -- who, like Champollion's at last reading Egyptian hieroglyphics -- has brought to life a musical past almost 3,000 years old.

Olivier MESSIAEN

…I looked with intense interest into the important discovery you have made on the biblical cantillation signs (…) Your extensive work deserves to be widely known and I wish you success in this important enterprise.

Darius MILHAUD

We are very happy that you were so willing to come to Jerusalem to give a conference on the biblical accents in the setting of a seminar at our Academy (…) After the various reactions we have heard, it seems that your musicological work is not only of great importance, but also of intense interest.

Mendi RODAN
Co-Director of the Rubin Academy of Music and Dance, Jerusalem

By the simple form and position of signs and tonic accents Madame HAÏK-VANTOURA has succeeded in making an overwhelming discovery. The results of this discovery are all the more remarkable since the prosody of the texts is scrupulously observed. This convergence between prosody and cantillation makes the discovery legitimate…

Henri SCHILLI
Chief Rabbi, Former Director of the Ecole Rabbinique de France

As an Israeli composer familiar with both Hebrew and the biblical cantillation of the various Jewish communities (…) I can attest to my profound amazement at Madame Suzanne HAÏK-VANTOURA's work in deciphering the cantillation signs of the Bible. Her strictly personal approach to the signs accompanying the biblical text led her to extraordinary results, in the exactitude of transmitting content as well as from a purely musical viewpoint (…) Madame Suzanne HAÏK-VANTOURA has succeeded in forming an organic whole, convincing by its mere simplicity.

Mordechai SETER
Recipient of the Italia Prize (1962) and the State of Israel Prize (1965)

…I consider this to be a major work of research from a musicological point of view, a real discovery of enormous importance. The deciphering is based on incontestable facts and the result of this "Benedictine labor" gives us a poetically fresh and penetrating song.

Alexandre TANSMAN


Updated November 05, 2008